The Hour I First Believed

Lamb, Wally. The Hour I First Believed. New York: HarperColliuns 2008. Print.

First Sentences:

They were both working their final shift at Blackjack Pizza that night, although nobody but the two of them realized it was that. Give them this much: they were talented secret-keepers.


Description:

This is a very difficult book for me to review and recommend. It is probably not for everyone since the backdrop is the shooting at Columbine High School on April 20, 1999. Given this violent background setting, this book probably doesn't sound like anything a sane person would want to read any more about, particularly if it's a 700-page historical novel. 

I, too, was one of those hesitant readers. But my interest in author Wally Lamb after reading his book, She's Come Undone, made me want to give The Hour I First Believed at least a fair try (you know, look at the first couple of sentences). And those words were enough to hook me.

I quickly realized that The Hour I First Believed was not simply a re-telling of that horrific incident, but rather a character study and journey towards recovery for one couple who experienced the shooting and the ensuing repercussions. The shooting itself is not completely avoided, of course. It is retold in bits and pieces, framed with some background information from the killers' actual diaries, videos, and interviews. So I kept reading and reading, becoming more and more involved in the main characters, their thoughts, fears, frustrations, and hopes.

The book centers on the fictional narrator, Caelum Quirk and his wife, Maureen, both long-time employees at Columbine High School. Caelum is a literature teacher while Maureen is the school's nurse. On the day of the shooting, Caelum was away from Colorado for a conference. But after seeing a live TV breaking news report on the shooting, he speeds homne, trying desperately to learn about the safety of this wife. He soon finds that Maureen, while safe, experienced first-hand the murderous boys words and actions, as well as saw their victims, most of whom she knew as students or as colleagues and friends. 

And after, she becomes a changed person....as does her husband.

We readers, through Caelem's stream-of-consciousness observations and interactions, follow this damaged couple as they try to address Maureen's new personality and fears, both together and singly. Each wonders whether they have done anything to have foreseen this tragedy or somehow acted to prevent even a small part of it. Questions, guilt, accusations, and self-examination fill their minds. 

In the days, week, months, and years, now, since they opened fire, I have searched wherever I could for the whys, hows, and whether-or-nots of Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold's rampage. They had been my students first, but I became theirs, stalking them so that I might rescue my wife from the aftermath of what they'd done.

And the couple must deal with other issues as well. Caelum is called on to settle the Connecticut estate and home of his recently-deceased aunt who helped raise him. Along the way, Caelum discovers documents, letters, and diaries in her attic  which reveal his true family history and heritage. Maureen, meanwhile, is trying to re-connect with a troubled student who disappeared during the shooting, as well as recover enough herself to return to work nursing.

You never really forgive yourself. At least I haven't ben able to. But if you can find ways to be useful to others, you can begin to figure out how to live inside your own skin, no matter what you did.

It's not a feel good read by any means, but definitely a fascinating, compelling character study of people dealing with trauma, never an easy process. It is also a well-researched depiction in what happened at Columbine, what it was like for the people who actually experienced it, and how those incidents affected one fictional couple, one community, and many, many lives ever after.

 

Fred

More book recommendations

About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Read, Shelley. Go As a River.   

A small town girl in rural Colorado has her life changed after one chance encounter which she must face and address for the rest of her life. (Previously reviewed here.)

Go As a River

Read, Shelley. Go As a River. New York: Spiegel & Grau 2023. Print.

First Sentences:

He wasn't much to look at. Not at first, anyway.


Description:

It's an intriguing title to Shelley Read's debut novel: Go As a River. In this compelling story of a young woman's life in the tiny town of Iola, Colorado in the late 1940's and beyond, this phrase pops up to describe a way to survive and continue living:

I had tried...to go as a river, but it had taken me a long while to understand what that meant. Flowing forward against obstacle was not my whole story. For, like the river, I had also gathered along the way all the tiny pieces connecting me to everything else, and doing this had delivered me here, with two fists of forest soil in my palms and a heart still learning to be unafraid of itself.

Victoria Nash, a seventeen-year-old girl, lives with her father, uncle, and younger brother on their generational peach ranch, serving the men in her family and helping with the crops after the deaths of her mother, aunt, and older brother in a auto accident five years earlier. She has no dreams of another life or the world outside her home and nearby woods until a young stranger drifts through town...and she is smitten.

God will bring two strangers together on the corner of North Laura and Main and lead them toward love. God won't make it easy. 

The consequences of her love for this outsider drive the remainder of the story as she leaves her home and family to be with this young man. But soon the reality of life in that era intrudes on the couple's world and both young people and their lives are forever changed.

 

That's all I will reveal of the compelling plot. But please know this is a very special tale of choices, survival, love, and family as seen through the narrator's (Victoria's) eyes and senses. She is passionate about her family and the natural world that surrounds her, and works to nurture and preserve both by whatever means available to her strength and determination. Her voice is true and strong, whether describing her surroundings or contemplating her doubts and obstacles she faces in her present and future life.

The old house smelled like only old houses do, like stories, like decades of buttery skillet breakfasts and black coffee and dripping faucets, like family and life and aging wood.

This is completely Victoria's story, although other major characters are depicted with skill and honesty by author Read. It is a dreamy book in some ways, but always under laid with the reality of the challenging world surrounding this young girl and her later adult years.

I was completely caught up in Victoria and her world, her intense will to survive as well as her heartfelt doubts about whichever road she decides to take. read's prose is simple and clear as the orchard and woods Victoria inhabits, exactly setting the tone on both innocence and gritty determination.

He would teach me how true a life emptied of all but its essentials could feel and that, when you got down to it, not much mattered outside the determination to go on living. 

Happy reading. 

 

Fred

More book recommendations

About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Doig, Ivan. The Whistling Season.   

A young, mysterious woman takes on work as housekeeper to a man and his sons on a small Montana farm. Along with her brother, she ingratiates herself into the family and community with long-reaching affects. Narrated by one of the young sons, it is a highly descriptive, delightful story of the people and events in a rural town. Absolutely one of the best books I have ever read. Highest recommendation.  (previously reviewed here)

 

Our Missing Hearts

Ng, Celeste. Our Missing Hearts. New York: Penguin. 2022. Print.

First Sentences:

The letter arrives on a Friday. Slit and resealed with a sticker, of course, as all their letters are: Inspected for your safety --- PACT. It had caused confusion at the post office, the clerk unfolding the paper inside, studying it, passing it up to his supervisor, then the boss. But eventually it had been deemed harmless and sent on its way. No return address, only a New York, NY postmark, six days old. On the outside, his name -- Bird -- and because of this he knows it is from his mother.


Description:

Seems like almost every week lately I have come across a new book that makes my top 10 all time list. Such was the case with Celeste Ng's Our Missing Hearts, a story that often hints at out current fearful society today in America and its repercussions on the people who must bend their lives to accommodate restrictive rules, government, and even neighbors intolerant of anything not patriotic or accepting of their new world.

You see, 12-year-old Noah (Byrd) Gardner lives in the United States under the laws created and enforced for the past ten years by PACT (The Preserving American Cultures and Traditions Act). These patriotism laws were overwhelming enacted in response to the worldwide Crisis, an international depression with joblessness, poverty, inflation, and ensuing riots. It was determined, without evidence, to have been brought on by the Chinese government and its people.

The Three Pillars of PACT: Outlaws promotion of un-American values and behavior: Requires all citizens to report potential threats to our society. Protects children from environments espousing harmful views.

Therefore, PACT forces everyone to promise allegiance, support, and love for the American government, while ostracizing anyone not meeting these goals in action or speech. Neighborhood Watch groups are everywhere, seeking out dissident opinions of actions and, if found, intensively questioning (or removing) the suspects. 

Children can be forcibly taken from homes of parents determined to be a bad influence and relocated to more suitable couples, never to be allowed to communicate with their biological parents. There are no protests of this action by parents since any questioning would contribute to the suspected parents' anti-PACT leanings, risking the real possibility that the children might never be returned.

Bird's mother had left him and his father three years earlier, never letting him know she was leaving and never corresponding with him until this note. It was a mysterious single sheet of paper without any words, filled with multiple drawings of cats and a tiny cupboard. 

Margaret, Byrd's mother, was a noted poet who had written the line "All our missing hearts" in one of her obscure poems. With these words, she had inadvertently created a slogan, a rallying phrase, that was taken up by an underground anti-PACT network. Her words appeared scrawled on walls, on signs, and other locations as the network tried to raise awareness of the seized children.

Margaret, despite knowing nothing about this loose organization, chooses to leave her home and go into hiding, protecting her husband Ethan and son who must now disavow all ties to her, her and especially her writing to insure Byrd (now called Noah) is not taken from his father as an "unsuitable influence."

With this new note, however, Noah takes on the challenge to find out more about his mother and hopefully locate her. 

Along the way, we read of Margaret's backstory, her life with Ethan, her word-loving husband and Noah's father, and the life she chooses to pursue while in hiding. Along with other notable friends, enemies, and "citizens" looking for any misstep by neighbors, Our Missing Hearts is both a gripping and heartfelt story, one filled with seeming hopelessness against a government of fear, and yet containing  a glimmer of hope from individuals trying to survive and make a difference in a twisted world.

Yes, yes, yes, I would recommend this book. It's a mystery, a warning, a breath of hope, and a gripping tale celebrating family strength. It's a book of friendship and secrets, fanaticism and consequences. But most of all, it is a deeply personal tale of perseverance toward achieving personal goals in order to understand one's self and the world, and how those two fit together now and in the future. Highest recommendation.

  

Happy reading. 

 

Fred

More book recommendations

About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Orwell, George. 1984.   

The classic and still important story of a totalitarian society and one man who tries to fight back.

 

She's Come Undone

Lamb, Wally. She's Come Undone. New York: Washington Square Press 1992. Print.

First Sentences:

In one of my earliest memories, my mother and I are on the front porch of our rented Carter Avenue house watching two deliverymen carry our brand-new television set up the steps. I'm excited because I've heard about but never seen television. The two men are wearing work clothes the same color as the box they're hefting between them. Like the crabs at Fisherman's Cove, they ascend the cement stairs sideways. Here's the undependable part: my visual memory stubbornly insists that these men are President Eisenhower and Vice President Nixon.


Description:

Wally Lamb's debut novel, She's Come Undone, follows Dolores Price, a challenging narrator to say the least, from age four until early adulthood. She has more than her share of obstacles in life, including a father who deserts her to start a new life and family elsewhere; a mother who plies her with sweets and junk and eventually is admitted to a mental institution; and a strict grandmother who ends up raising her. Dolores deals with her world cynically and judgmentally from the confines of her bedroom until her depressed eating brings her weight to over 270 pounds. Although she is accepted into a college, this is her mother's dream, not hers, and she is reluctant to attend.

 

She does meet and retain several acquaintances and eventually a husband who assists her mentally and later financially. But really she meets the world alone, on her terms, and confidently chooses her own pathways.

Sounds depressing, huh? Well, it can be. But honestly, you just have to pull for Dolores amid all her troubles, both those inflicted on her by circumstances as well as those she pursues willingly to disastrous ends. You just have to stick with her and see how she can find a way to pull herself into the woman she has inside her, buried under layers of cynicism, doubt, fear, and false confidence.

 

Lamb is a captivating writer, a master of inner stream-of-consciousness narration, dialogue, and insightful depictions of characters. He keeps you reading page after page to see what new dilemma or person will come into Dolores' life that she will have to examine (often superficially), judge (usually harshly), and react to (angrily). Lamb makes readers feel the conflicts, fears, and hope of Dolores with every situation she finds herself thrown into.

I was fully invested in Dolores and this book for its honest presentation of a young girl coming of age, trying to find herself, and confronting the world and people she faces. It's a modern re-imagining of The Catcher in the Rye, but with a female lead who reveals herself and her angst much more clearly and empathically, in my mind, that Holden Caulfield ever did. 

[P.S. For another great coming of age novel, please read one of my favorites, Brewster by Mark Slouka (see below)]

 

Happy reading. 

 

Fred

More book recommendations

About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Slouka, Mike. Brewster.   

My favorite coming of age book with four remarkable, memorable characters who loosely bond together and battle against their personal struggles as teens. A fine successor to The Catcher in the Rye. (previously reviewed here)

Cold People

Smith, Tom Rob. Cold People. New York: Scribner 2023. Print.

First Sentences:

Looking up at the night sky Ui saw only unfamiliar stars. 

These weren't the constellations that guided him between the Polynesian islands of his homeland, these were stars from the sky's outer edge, the stars his people had never bothered to name since they were no use to navigate by, dismissed at the "petuu vare" - foolish stars.

Description:

When a huge number of alien spaceships suddenly appear in the morning sky, a strange message plays on every electronic device in the world, plugged in or not: "People have thirty days to reach the continent of Antarctica." Nothing else. No reason why. No consequences revealed. Just that simple ominous message.

So starts the brilliant, challenging Cold People by Tom Rob Smith. The first contact with another species leads to a hurried mass migration of the world's people to the frozen south. Military boats, planes, oil tankers, and anything else that flies or floats is re-outfitted to carry as many passengers as possible, but of course they are insufficient in capacity to transport every person on Earth.

Those who somehow do reach Antarctica must create a completely new world when their old one is destroyed. No nations, no electronics, no internet, no money, everyone equal. These early challenges are only briefly addressed as author Smith quickly takes the story twenty years into the future after the aliens' arrival. And by then things have definitely changed for the people still alive in Antarctica.

By the end of the first year, it was apparent that humankind wouldn't survive unless it unified. Old notions of sovereignty were a luxury it could no longer afford. 

Realizing that humans are frail and completely unsuited to continuing in this bitter cold environment, much less expanding their population, the scientists among them create the "Cold People" project. They begin altering genetic material to produce "ice-adapted" humans who will be able to tolerate and thrive under icy conditions far beyond what current people could ever hope to achieve.

But there are questionable outcomes to this genetic experimentation, both ethical and dangerous, and the fate of the Antarctic  communities and mankind in general rest in the mysterious creations produced in the experimental labs.

This is a story of survival to be sure. But it is also presents thoughtful scenario where families, love, relationships, and ethics all must be reexamined to face and hopefully succeed in a challenging present and highly-uncertain future. I feel the unexpected directions taken by highly unusual characters in unique situations make this a strong narrative that will capture the attention and encourage philosophical and ethical questions in the minds of most readers.

 

Happy reading. 

 

Fred

More book recommendations

About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Stephenson, Neil. Seveneves.   

When the moon explodes on the very first page of this novel, humankind must work together to construct a method to somehow preserve mankind and the knowledge of the ages before Earth eventually is destroyed. Riveting.  (previously reviewed here)

English Creek

 Doig, Ivan. English Creek. New York: Antheneum 1984. Print

First Sentences:

That month of June swam into the Two Medicine country. In my life until then I had never seen the sidehills come so green, the coulees stay so spongy with runoff. A right amount of wet evidently could sweeten the universe.


Description:

Sometimes I need a book just to curl up with and sink into like a soft, downy comforter, sitting in a comfy chair near a good light in front of the fireplace. At these times, I need a book that describes real people living in interesting locations, doing ordinary activities. But the writing and the people must be so genuinely honest and clear, like a cool zephyr breeze on a muggy summer day. With these conditions, I cannot help but sit back and relish everything about such a reading experience. It is unique, calming, and highly enjoyable, no matter how all too brief the warmth and clarity of the people, setting, and writing exist with me.

Such a book is my highly recommended novel by Ivan Doig, English Creek. It tells of life in an isolated Montana community in 1939, an area surrounded by forests, a river, and sheep ranches run by neighbors whose families have been in the area for generations. Narrated by 14-year-old Jick McCaskill, he decribes what he lives through one paticular summer: moving sheep to the high fields, a Fourth of July rodeo and dance, ice cream making, youthful friends and loves, and a frightening forest fire (his father is the local ranger). Jick shares his philosophical thoughts behind moving an outhouse which required breaking virgin sod for the first time and prying up unending amounts of rock from the stony field. He felt his outhouse-moving experience justified the county's reputation as "a toupee of grass on a cranium of rock." 

 

Has there ever been a better description of a small town July 4th celebration and its affect on those who join in the festivities as Jick's summation below:

If a sense of life, of the blood racing beneath your skin, is not with you at a Fourth of July creek picnic, then it is never going to be.

While this plot description may sound rather tepid, I prefer to call it "quiet," "immersive" and "deeply satisfying." It's not a book to breeze through. It is a pleasure to languish in Two Medicine county for as long as possible to watch Jick face challenges, understand his family better, and learn of the history of that small community. And the people he lives among each has a story to tell in their manner and actions, and in their spare, well-considered words. Here are a sampling of his neighbors:

• Ed Heaney, who "served in France during the war...[but] didn't want to squander one further minute of his life talking about it."
• Earl Zane, who was "built as if he'd been put together out of railroad ties"...with a face "as clear as the label on a maple sugar jar [that] proclaimed SAP."
  
• Velma, with her tiny pearl button earrings "as if her ears could be unbottoned to further secrets even there."
  
• Toussaint Rennie, who was "one of those chuckling men you meet rarely, able to stave off time by perpetually staying in such high humor that the years didn't want to interrupt him." 
• Perry Fox, who was "slow as the wrath of Christ, but steady."
  
• Jink's mother, of whom his father said, "I think that being married to you is worth all the risk." 
  

I simply loved this book, its attention to quiet detail and its clarity of writing. Conversations seem easy to listen to, people appear subtly complex, and the environment always presents a force that beckons to be explored and appreciated. I think everyone should indulge in this encompassing look into a world we rarely glimpse, much less easily comprehend today.

Best of all, this is the first in a trilogy of the McCaskill family life in Two Medicine, Montana: Dancing at the Rascal Fair and Ride With Me, Mariah Montana. Can't wait to indulge myself in these next two absorbing books.

Happy reading. 

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Doig, Ivan. The Whistling Season.   

A Chicago woman in 1909 answers an advertisement for a housekeeper for a widower and his three young sons living in an isolated Montana town. She writes that she "Can't cook, but doesn't bite," and gets the job sight unseen (by both of them). She brings her brother with her on the train and he reluctantly becomes a unique schoolteacher. Simply wonderful, a great read not to be missed.  (previously reviewed here)

For the Love of Cod

Dregni, Eric. For the Love of Cod: A Father and Son's Search for Norwegian Happiness. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota 2021. Print

First Sentences:

My dad took me to Scandinavia when I was sixteen. Now it was my turn to take my son. The only problem was I didn't have the money.


Description:

If you ever plan to go on a trip to Norway as my wife and I did this past spring, or if you are curious about the people, environment, and culture of this Scandinavian country, then please explore Eric Dregni's For the Love of Cod: A Father and Son's Search for Norwegian Happiness

 

This is a personal, often humorous chronicle of a journey taken by the author with his son, Eilif, to visit the country of his son's birth. Since author Dregni did not have much money for hotels, he and Eilif stayed with relatives, friends of relatives, and friends of friends of relatives. This personal living situation allowed opportunities for much discussion with natives regarding Norwegian values, lifestyles, customs, oil fund income, the Nobel Prize (awarded in Oslo), taxes, environment, tunnels, and of course, food (whale anyone?), all of which Dregni shares his readers.

These inner workings of Norway are presented in a conversational tone as Dregni observes and learns about the country where he briefly once lived and where Eilif was born. Readers really get to know and understand this Norwegian world and its people through Dregni's questions and his hosts' opinions. Under discussion are issues such as:

• Volunteering - the expected communal work, or dugnad, where "All neighbors chip in and help because you never know when you'll need the help";
• Education - no grades are given until eighth grade "to downplay competition and build up self-confidence," and barnehager or outdoor education which begins during ages 1-5;
• Happiness - lykkelig or "make your own luck and happiness." The people live by the Norwegian expression, "Happy are those who have passion."
• Hiking - "Out on a walk, never cross." Grumpy kids are given a "Norwegian rucksack" packed for adventure, containing a sweater, a swimsuit, an umbrella, sandwiches, and a Kvikk Luns ("quick lunch") candy bar, then sent outside.

I loved learning about the concern over Tunnelfeber (tunnel fever) as Norway builds more and more tunnels to shorten road trips that previously required ferries or twisty, out-of-the-way roads. These new miles-long tunnels, however, block the views and, for many citizens, ruin their connection to nature. 

From bunads (traditional dress for women) and the busybody Bunad Police who check to make sure this clothing is authentic, to the Easter Chicken ("Why would a rabbit bring around eggs?"), to the Sakte (slow) lifestyle, exemplified by the most popular Norwegian television show ever: a 134-hour video taken from a fixed camera on the prow of a boat during a six-day boat ride from Bergen to the Kirkenes on the Russian border), For the Love of Cod is a fascinating look into Norway and its culture, told by a conversational, curious, and funny narrator and the wide variety of Norwegians he interacts with. Thoroughly delightful, even if you never plan to visit this wonderful country. Highly recommended.

Happy reading. 

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

O'Reilly and Larry Habegger. Travelers' Tales: India.   

A vast collection of personal observations, reflections, experiences, and conversations from actual visitors to India. From Benaras to Mumbai to the Taj Mahal, to the Golden Temple, each traveler paints an authentic and emotional portrait of this complex country and its people.

Housekeeping

Robinson, Marilynne. Housekeeping. New York: Picador 1980. Print

First Sentences:
 

My name is Ruth. I grew up with my younger sister, Lucille, under the care of my grandmother, Mrs. Sylvia Foster, and when she died, of her sisters-in-law, Misses Lily and Nona Foster, and when they fled, of her daughter, Mrs. Sylvia Fisher.


Description:

As you probably noticed, I haven't posted any book recommendations for several months. Chalk it up to a severe case of reader's block. Nothing I tried to read during the COVID pandemic seemed to capture my attention. Fiction seemed too frivolous. Non-fiction too detailed. Humor? Forget it with everything going on politically and health-wise.

 

So what to do? I decided to pick up some old reliable favorite from past reading experience that never fails to satisfy. I have several of these that I turn to when desperate for the restorative power of great writing, characters, plot, and setting. My favorite reliables? J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings, Farley Mowat's Never Cry Wolf, P.G. Wodehouse's The Golf Omnibus, Ray Bradbury's The Martian Chronicles, and W. Somerset Maugham's Complete Short Stories 

 

This time I returned (after too many years away) to Marilynne Robinson's Housekeeping. It's a very quiet, but unsettling novel about two young girls: narrator Ruth and younger sister Lucille, who are placed in the care of a quirky, distant aunt, Sylvia, after the suicide of their mother.

 

Sylvia is a drifter, a wanderer, living her life (by choice) riding trains, with no home, no ties, and no plans for the future. But she is coerced into settling back into her family home with these two young girls who need an adult. They live in their family home in the bone-chilling isolation of Fingerbone, Colorado on the shores of a mighty lake, the very same water that claimed the lives of their grandfather in a spectacular train wreck and their mother who drove off a cliff into it.

 

Sylvia is definitely not a homemaker, with her casual attention to orderliness, schedules, promises, food, and clothing. She is taken to wandering the neighborhoods through the night, "borrowing" a boat and rowing to secret locations. and hoarding newspapers stacked high in the house. But when her actions are questioned by authorities enough to removed the girls from her care, she proves to be fiercely protective of their small family and her role in it.

 

Eventually the girls respond to her lifestyle, each one choosing to either rebel or accept her quirks into their own lives. Their adolescent development and growth in trying to understand the mysteries of Sylvia slowly, steadily work to portray a picture of survival, family, and choices.

 

I loved this book, although, fair warning, it may not be for everyone. It paints a picture of life among people struggling to understand their place in the world, how choices affect them and others, all  set in a very cold, grey, vaguely ominous environment. But for readers interested in storytelling and writing at its best, I highly recommend Housekeeping.

Happy reading. 

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Doig, Ivan. The Whistling Season.   

A Chicago woman in 1909 answers an advertisement for a housekeeper from a widower and his three young sons living in an isolated Montana town. She writes that she "Can't cook, but doesn't bite," and gets the job sight unseen (by both of them). She brings her brother with her on the train and he reluctantly becomes a unique schoolteacher. Simply wonderful, a great read not to be missed.  (previously reviewed here)

Life Among the Savages

 Jackson, Shirley. Life Among the Savages. New York: Farrar, Straus and Young. 1948. Print

First Sentences:

Our house is old, and noisy, and full.

When we moved into it we had two children and about five thousand books; I expect that when we finally overflow and move out again we will have perhaps twenty children and easily half a million books....

I cannot think of a preferable way of life, except one without children....


Description:

Shirley Jackson is best known for her creepy short story, "The Lottery" with its surprise, horrifying ending. But in a completely different vein is her humorous memoir of her family adventures in their everyday world, Life Among the Savages, which details her life with husband and children in rural New Hampshire.

After getting a notice of eviction from their New York City apartment due to the forgotten end date of their lease, Jackson, husband, and two children knew they had to look for a larger place outside the city. But they delayed their search out of procrastination until just days before being kicked out of their apartment. Then they remembered friends who had successfully re-located to a small town in New Hampshire. So Jackson's family finally started (and ended) their house search there.

The house hunt is the first adventure she relates. An agent in the rural town shows them only places to buy (despite their protestations that the Jacksons wanted to rent a normal house). All had no plumbing, were falling down or without heat, often all the above. 

Once settled, Jackson gives us stories of their highly-personable children, starting with son Laurie's first day of school:

The day Laurie started kindergarten he renounced corduroy overalls with bibs and began wearing blue jeans with a belt; ...an era of my life was ended, my sweet-voiced nursery-school tot replaced by a long-trousered, swaggering character who forgot to stop at the corner and wave goodbye to me.

Laurie came home with lots of stories in the first weeks of school, all involving a fellow student named Charles, who did one bad thing after another and was punished by their teacher. Biting, saying nasty words, and throwing chalk, Charles became a fascinating character in the Jackson family's life. Jackson herself was incredibly curious to meet Charles' mother and see what kind of woman could raise such a mischievous boy. Then came the first parent-teacher night when she found out from Laurie's teacher that Laurie had taken some time to adjust to school ... and that there was no Charles in the class. 

Jackson's imaginative daughter Jannie gets her share of coverage. 

Daughter Jannie (age 5) went by Mrs. Ellenoy, "the second Mrs. Ellenoy," because the first had died and left her with 7 daughters all named Martha. 

Jackson's husband, usually a quiet figure in the family adventures, was the central figure of a wonderful story involving his air gun (bought for "target practice"), their pet cat, a chipmunk, and a bat that all came together inside the house. 

Other delightful tales included:

• When the family thinks about buying a car (their first since no one knew how to drive) and the ensuing arguments about who would get to sit in the front passenger seat. Of course, after they finally do get a car, son Laurie decides he'd rather have a plane, and the fights renew over who would get to sit on the wing.

• When Father and son bond over coin collecting, but are dismayed to find one shipment that contains both a bag of valuable coins as well as a bag of counterfeit coins. The bags had burst, accidently scattering the real and fake coins together to be somehow sorted over the weeks to come.

Life Among the Savages is just a lovely, clever, funny, and completely believable accounting of a normal family living an everyday life in a small town. Absolutely delightful in all ways, a welcome antidote to our grouchy, pandemic-stay-at-home blues.

Happy reading.

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Gilbreth, Franklin B. Cheaper by the Dozen.   

Memoirs of a family with twelve, yes that's 12, children, iled by the quirky father, a famous time-management expert who tries to regulate the learning and activities of the household. Don't need to say any more except that it is cleverly written and extremely funny, full of wonderful stories.

Plainsong

Haruf, Kent. Plainsong. New York: Knopf 1999. Print

First Sentences:

Here was the man, Tom Guthrie, in Holt standing at the back window in the kitchen of his house smoking cigarettes and looking out over the back lot where the sun was just coming up.

When the sun reached the top of the windmill, for a while he watched what it was doing, that increased reddening of sunrise along the steel blades and the tail vane above the wooden platform.


Description:

Seventee miles outside the tiny town of Holt, Colorado live two elderly batchelor farmer brothers, Raymond and Harold McPheron. They keep to themselves, tending their fields and animals in quiet seclusion, barely speaking to each other much less anyone else. They've lived all their lives since their early teens when their parents died.

But their familiar world changes suddenly in Kent Haruf's Plainsong when they are asked to accept into their household a pregnant teenage girl, Victoria Roubideaux, who has nowhere else to go and no one to care for her. These gruff, unpolished men now must deal with this tiny, quiet girl and her coming baby, privately and in their own inexperienced manner.

[Harold said]...why, hell, look at us. Old men alone. Decrepit old bachelors out here in the courtry seventeen miles from the closest town which don't amount to much of a good goddamn even when you get there. Think of us. Crotchety and ignorant. Lonesome. Independent. Sent in all our ways. How you going to change now at this age of life?

I can't say, Raymond said. But I'm going to. That's what I know.

But in a small town, no one can long keep their lives private. In Holt, that holds true of other stolid townspeople who quietly carry their own burdens. For example, Tom Gutherie, the high school teacher, trying to raise his sons alone while his wife chooses to remain alone in her room upstairs in their home. He also suffers the trials of recalcitrant students and the wrath of their parents.

You get to know and even partially understand the lives of other characters: Maggie Jones, the teacher who befriends Victoria and introduces her to the batchelor brothers; Mrs. Sterns, the ancient woman living alone amongst the items she has hoarded for years: Dwayne, the Denver boy who is the father of Victoria's baby; and Russell Beckman, the school bully.

The descriptions of this landscape and these seemingly ordinary people sets Plainsong apart from almost every other book. Take Haruf's description of Tom's sons sleeping together in one bed:

...the older boy had one hand stretched above his brother's head as if he hopes to shove something away and thereby save them both. They were nine and ten, with dark brown hair and unmarked faces, and cheeks that were still as pure and dear as a girl's.

Then there is simple, moving description of the town doctor who examines Victoria so tenderly:

The old doctor reached up and took her hand and held it warmly between both of his hands for a moment and was quiet with her, simply looking into her face, serenely, grandfatherly, but not talking, treating her out of respect and kindness, out of his own long experience of patients in examination rooms.

These are characters that make you want to cry for their realness, determination, and inner passions. Their lives intertwine as they must do in small towns. To watch their interactions first occur, then blossom, wither, or triumph, all beautifully written by Kent Haruf, makes Plainsong a truly wonderful book. Please read it. It has my highest recommendation.

Happy reading. 

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Doig, Ivan. The Whistling Season.   

A Chicago woman in 1909 answers an advertisement for a housekeeper for a widower and his three young sons living in an isolated Montana town. She writes that she "Can't cook, but doesn't bite," and gets the job sight unseen (by both of them). She brings her brother with her on the train and he reluctantly becomes a unique schoolteacher. Simply wonderful, a great read not to be missed.  (previously reviewed here)

Lying in Wait

Nugent, Liz. Lying in Wait. New York: Scout 2016. Print

First Sentences:

My husband did not mean to kill Annie Doyle, but the lying tramp deserved it.

After we had overcome the initial shock, I tried to stop him speaking of her. I did not allow it unless to confirm alibis or to discuss covering up any possible evidence. It upset him too much and I thought it best to move on as if nothing had happened.

Description:

If you are looking for an ordinary thriller or good mystery, then Liz Nugent's novel Lying in Wait, may not be exactly what you might expect. Why? Well, from the first sentences, the reader knows about the crime, who committed it, and who successfully covers it up without a trace.

What Lying in Wait offers that is so intriguing, however, is the psychological effects such a perfect crime has on both the perpetrators, the families of the victim, and innocent bystanders who get roped into the whole affair.

After Annie Doyle is killed for mysterious reasons by the husband and wife team of Andrew and Lydia Fitzsimons, it falls to Lydia to face the reality of the crime and make sure everyone resumes their normal lives, a task not easily acceptable to Andrew. They do agree it is important to keep the crime secret from their son, Laurence, who is becoming curious about some irregularities stemming from the lies of his parents, not to mention the new garden mound that appears in their back yard.

Also, there is Annie's sister, Karen, who simply will not let go of the disappearance of her sister in spite of the disinterest from the police, her family, and friends. That all changes when Karen's life becomes inadvertently intertwined with the Fitzsimons in the most clever, nerve-tingling way. 

Lying in Wait is not a thriller exactly and certainly not a gruesome mystery in any way beyond the quick murder on the first page. Rather, it is a book chock full of nail-biting anxiety as people dip closer to each other and towards untangling the mystery so near them. 

Readers simply cannot predict how these characters will react or how it all will end, whether for better or worse. But I am here to tell you it is one of the most satisfying, interesting endings of any book I have ever read. You have to love a story that keeps you guessing right up to the last pages, then fulfills your expectations for resolution in an completely unexpected way.

A gripping, unique read that I highly recommend.

Happy reading. 

Fred

Other book recommendations
About The First Sentence Reader blog

____________________

If this book interests you, be sure to check out:

Lutz, Lisa. The Passenger.   

Tonya, finding her husband dead at the bottom of the stairs in their home (presumable from a fall), decides the police will never believe she didn't murder him. So she takes it on the lam, driving through the country, changing identities, jobs, and her own back stories as she goes. But she knows that someday she will be caught and then what? A compelling story with a clever, unique narrator.  (previously reviewed here)